Lot 219 · 19th-Century Works of Art: Featuring Works from The Muriel S. and Noah L. Butkin Collection Sold to Benefit the Cleveland Museum of Art
Arrival of the Pilgrims
Sign in to download a work market report (PDF) — placement, comparables, and the artist's market, generated from the record.
- Estimate
- $8,000–$12,000 hammer
- Result
- Performance
- Sale
- Sotheby's — 19th-Century Works of Art: Featuring Works from The Muriel S. and Noah L. Butkin Collection Sold to Benefit the Cleveland Museum of Art, New York · 24 May 2023
- Record ID
- TB-2026-5127364
- Record
- first seen 28 Jul 2026 · updated 6 Sep 2026 · source ↗
- Cite this record
- TB-2026-5127364 — https://thebasis.art/cite/TB-2026-5127364
Charles Murray Padday, Arrival of the Pilgrims. Sotheby's, 24 May 2023, lot 219. bought in (did not sell). TheBasis.Art, TB-2026-5127364.
Cite this record permanent · resolvable · quotable
Appraisal reports, insurance claims, catalogue entries and footnotes. The identifier never changes, and anyone can resolve it back to this page at https://thebasis.art/cite/TB-2026-5127364.
Charles Murray Padday, Arrival of the Pilgrims. Sotheby's, 24 May 2023, lot 219. bought in (did not sell). TheBasis.Art, TB-2026-5127364.
The citation omits the realized price because this record is not unlocked. Everything else in it is complete and permanent.
From the same sale 19th-Century Works of Art: Featuring Works from The Muriel S. and Noah L. Butkin Collection Sold to Benefit the Cleveland Museum of Art · May 2023
| Lot | Artist | Estimate | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Near the Salève | Francois Diday | $3,000–$5,000 | |
| Along the Canal | Rubens Santoro | $30,000–$50,000 | |
| Self-Portrait | Marcellin Gilbert Desboutin | $10,000–$15,000 | |
| Fantasia | Ulpiano Checa | $7,000–$9,000 | |
| Cornish Coast | David James | $5,000–$7,000 | |
| Moss Brook, Biddeford Pool, Maine (August-September 1916) | Louis Aston Knight | $10,000–$15,000 |
Comparable results nearest sold works, same medium & price band
| Artist | Lot | vs. estimate | Result USD, incl. premium | Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charles Murray Padday | charles murray padday | the harbour at bougie, algeria | $9,426 | Sotheby's, Jul 2019 | |
| Charles Murray Padday | Sunset on the garden path | Bonhams, Nov 2018 | ||
| Charles Murray Padday | Unloading the catch | Bonhams, Apr 2025 | ||
| Montague Dawson | Ships at night | Bonhams, Apr 2021 | ||
| Charles Edward Dixon | RMS Etruria rescuing the crew of the foundering SS Millfield | Bonhams, May 2020 | ||
| Thomas Luny | Portrait of the East Indiaman Neptune in two positions off t | Bonhams, Apr 2022 | ||
| Montague Dawson | Flicker in Gold – The Forest Queen | Freeman's | Hindman, Sep 2022 | ||
| Charles Murray Padday | dividing the spoil | Sotheby's, Dec 2018 |
The closest sold results by price, artist, and medium — the appraiser's comp set, generated from the corpus. All figures converted to USD at current reference rates.